In late 2022, our client, then 26, dated a woman, then age 27, who he met online on a Christian dating website.
The woman told our client that she had been raped by a former boyfriend and when she told the police about the experience, she was discredited and nothing happened. She took several years to overcome the experience and remarked that having no sex for several years “makes me a virgin again.”
Our client and the woman met a few times in person, including her coming over to his apartment in Garden Grove several times for dinner and going to a gym together, too. Our client had only given her a quick kiss here and there.
One evening, on their fourth date, she came over to our client’s apartment for dinner. She was wearing a tight-fitting dress that accentuated her figure. She also brought our client flowers.
After dinner at his place, the two sat on the couch and our client attempted to snuggle next to her. The woman reciprocated and put her arm around him.
Our client then attempted to kiss her and put his hands on the alleged victim’s shoulders and thighs. The woman did not reciprocate his affection. Instead, she left and coldly broke off all contact with our client. This puzzled our client, but he suspected she had flashbacks to being raped by her prior boyfriend. In other words, she was unreasonably sensitive to this gentle affection.
Months later, he found out she had reported the incident to the police. He then called our office and asked what he should do because a deputy from the Orange County Sheriff’s Department left him a message to call him.
The client then explained to Greg what had happened. The client explained that he had no prior criminal history. He was in the United States on a work visa from Mexico. His English was perfect.
The client then explained how his “girlfriend” had called him back and accused him of being overly aggressive with her and that he apologized to her, but told her he did not think he was overly aggressive. Greg explained that this phone call, called a “pretext call,” likely was monitored by the Orange County Sheriff’s Department, and that his “girlfriend” was coached in how to ask questions to elicit an admission or confession from our client, or at least an apology.
Greg then explained how such cases typically proceed in court, although in this case, the conduct was very minor. Greg emphasized that in this case, the difficult thing would be trying to resolve the case with no adverse immigration consequences. The client then retained Greg Hill & Associates.
Greg called the deputy back and explained that our client had retained Greg Hill & Associates and he would not be speaking to the deputy.
A few weeks after retaining our office, the client received a letter from the Orange County Superior Court notifying him that a complaint had been filed against him and that an arraignment was calendared for August 1, 2023.
The client then called Greg Hill and discussed the letter. Greg recommended that the client speak with a bail bondsman and fill out all paperwork necessary to post a bond, but not pay anything until the judge rules on whether bail will be required.
The letter stated that a complaint against our client had been filed alleging a violation of California Penal Code §§ 220 (Assault with Intent to Commit a Sex Offense), 243.4 (sexual battery) and 236 / 237 (false imprisonment).
Greg then discussed each charge with the client and explained that the only way to navigate around adverse immigration consequences and registering as a sex offender for life (or less under Senate Bill 384) was through an Allexy plea (People v Toni Allexy (2012) 204 Cal.App.4th 1358, 139 Cal.Rptr.3d 723) or “split plea” wherein our client would enter a plea to a charge that requires registration as a sex offender, but sentencing is put over for a year or two to allow defendant to complete sex offender classes or therapy and perhaps perform community service. If the defendant fulfills the therapy requirements, the judge will dismiss the charge requiring registration and/or causing adverse immigration effects (although technically, the plea itself has adverse consequences in immigration court until it is withdrawn).
Over the next fourteen months, Greg and the client appeared in court, first in the Westminster Courthouse and later in the Santa Ana Courthouse (after the preliminary hearing).
As it turned out, the “girlfriend” told the police that our client lifted her up over his shoulder and carried her (a difficult task because she was quite heavy, being over 200 pounds) to his bedroom, where he attempted to rape her for 45 minutes, but could not get her clothes off. The story included a claim that she ran to the apartment front door and could not exit because our client locked the door with a key from inside, which was impossible. The story was unrealistic in many other ways.
Ultimately, the plea bargain offered to our client went from three years in state prison to a delayed entry of judgment. Our client entered a plea to a misdemeanor violation of Penal Code § 243.4 and a felony violation of Penal Code § 236 and sentencing was put over for a year.
During the year, our client would be required to attend 30 sexual impulse control classes (he already attended sixteen) and to perform 15 days of community service.
If our client attends 14 more sexual impulse control classes and performs the community service, he will be permitted to withdraw his plea to the 243.4 charge (preventing a conviction for a crime of moral turpitude and a requirement to register as a sex offender) and enter his plea to a violation of Penal Code § 236 only, which is a wobbler and can be reduced to a misdemeanor later, preventing adverse immigration consequences.