Our client, age 29, went into the Sephora store on the Third Street Promenade in Santa Monica and proceeded to take one crème contour stick, remove the packaging on it and place it in her purse. She then did the same thing with six lips products. The put the empty boxes for each item back on the products shelves in the store.
Our client then tried to walk out with the items (worth $328) without paying and was stopped. When loss prevention spoke with her and asked to look into our client’s purse, our client explained that she had no idea how such products got into her purse. Loss prevention then played the store security video of her and asked her if she wanted to reconsider her answer. She said she would not.
Sephora’s loss prevention then called the Santa Monica Police Department, who arrived at the store and took our client, in handcuffs, to their station, where she was booked and held for several hours while police ran a nationwide warrant check on her.
When the client was allowed to leave, she signed a promise to appear in the Airport Superior Court in about two months.
She then scoured the Internet and called Greg Hill & Associates. She explained to Greg that she was a graduate student taking seventeen units in the current semester and was working toward her Ph.D. She explained also that she was in the United Staes on a Student Visa from Kuala Lumpur, but she was originally from Iran. She had no prior criminal history and wanted to know what Greg could do to prevent her being convicted of petty theft and then not being able to renew her Student Visa. The client was hoping to pursue a career in academia, so having any conviction would be devastating, particularly one involving dishonesty.
Greg explained that he would suggest directly to the Santa Monica City Attorney’s Office that our client’s case be referred to an office hearing or the Neighborhood Justice Program instead of being filed. Greg then explained what an office hearing was and what the Neighborhood Justice Program was all about.
Greg then suggested that the client enroll in and complete the Third Millennium “Stoplifting” online theft prevention course and then send Greg her proof of completion of this program.
Greg also asked for a photocopy of our client’s Student Visa and proof of her heavy academic load, which she was taking online from a university in Georgia while living in Los Angeles.
The client then enrolled in and completed the “Stoplifting” program sent Greg her proof of completion of the online class. She also sent Greg a photocopy of her Student Visa and proof of her academic load.
Greg then mailed and emailed the filing attorney at the Santa Monica City Attorney’s office a short letter requesting pre-filing diversion in an office hearing or referral to the Neighborhood Justice Program. Remarkably, the filing attorney responded by email and promised to review the police report.
A few days later, after reviewing the police report, the filing deputy responded to Greg’s letter, stating that he found our client defiant and that she stole a high value of items from Sephora, so the case would be filed. However, he would offer her City Attorney diversion with a dismissal after 90 days if she performed three days (24 hours) of community labor.
While the client was somewhat disappointed that she was rejected for an office hearing or the Neighborhood Justice Program, she was happy nonetheless that she would have the opportunity to “earn a dismissal” and later have the arrest report and the record of the case filing sealed under Penal Code § 851.91, as Greg explained.
Greg then appeared in the Airport Superior Court on the client’s behalf on the date of the arraignment and entered into City Attorney diversion on the client’s behalf. The client was happy with this resolution, as she would preserve her ability to renew her Student Visa (no plea of no contest or guilty was entered) and later have the opportunity to have the police report sealed.