In early September 2024, a weekday, our client was struggling with alcohol. He was 42 years old and married, with two children.
Although it was still in the morning, he had started drinking. At about noon, he was driving his Ford 150 pickup northbound on Pacific Coast Highway through Redondo Beach. He would later say he did not know where he was headed, as he worked from home and had no reason to be driving northbound on Pacific Coast Highway, away from his home.
This was the last memory he had of the morning, as he “blacked out” from drinking and only regained awareness of his surroundings hours later in the Redondo Beach Police Department.
His wife called Greg Hill & Associates later in the afternoon to discuss what she knew, which was only that her husband had been involved in a traffic accident while drunk. She knew it was his third DUI, although his prior two were more than ten years earlier, or so she thought.
She wanted to retain an attorney because she was told the other party to the collision was injured and she also knew her husband would need legal representation in the DUI case.
Greg explained how a DUI with injuries can be prosecuted in California, depending upon the severity of the injuries to the other party and the defendant’s criminal history and blood alcohol content. Greg also explained how the DMV may proceed both in an admin per se context related to the DUI and in negligence context related to a car accident.
The wife, on her husband’s behalf (he was in custody), retained Greg Hill & Associates and our office then reserved a DMV hearing.
About two weeks before the hearing, our office received the Redondo Beach DUI Arrest Report, as well as a traffic collision report and the Age 21 and Older Officer’s Statement (the DS-367).
The documents reported that as our client, while on Pacific Coast Highway, approached Avenue H, the traffic light turned red and cars in front of our client came to a stop, but our client did not. He ran into the rear end of a red Tesla sedan driven by a 67 year old man from Palos Verdes. After running into the car, our client then ran into him a second time by hitting his accelerator again and, it seemed, trying to leave the scene or just continue north on Pacific Coast Highway.
A witness looked over at our client after the collision and saw our client drinking alcohol while still seated in his stopped truck at the scene, before exiting. He then exited his truck, stumbled to the nearby sidewalk and laid down.
The Redondo Beach Police Department came to the scene and reported finding empty White Claw wine coolers and empty Smirnoff Ice bottles inside the truck’s driver area.
The report did not state the time of the accident (when our client last drove).
At the scene, our client submitted to a breath test on a preliminary alcohol screening (PAS) device and his breath was measured at 0.22% and 0.25% BAC. The observant reader will note that this variance, 0.03%, exceeds the maximum allowed under California Title 17, so such BAC evidence would be inadmissible. Moreover, since our client consumed alcohol after driving, the BAC measured was certainly not his BAC when he was last driving. It was not known how much alcohol our client drank after the collision.
The injuries to the other driver were not clear, although the other driver was transported from the scene by an ambulance, but that may have been precautionary only.
Our client was apparently not injured, but he was taken to Little Company of Mary Hospital in Torrance to be evaluated. He was found indeed to be uninjured and then submitted to a blood test.
Our client’s blood sample was measured to have a blood alcohol content of 0.25%.
At the DMV Hearing, Greg argued that the DMV could not find that our client’s BAC was 0.08% or higher because a witness described in the police reports stated he observed our client drinking alcohol after the accident before exiting his vehicle. While our client’s BAC was more than three times the legal limit, there was no description of how much our client drank after the accident. Theoretically, he might have been sober before the collision and his BAC was entirely attributable to the alcohol he drank after the collision.
The DMV agreed and set aside the suspension of our client’s driver’s license.
We present this summary because it exemplifies an unusual set of facts, but also the value of reserving a DMV Hearing even when one regards the facts as hopeless. Here, there were unexpected facts in the police report that allowed our client to restore his driving privileges.